The St. John’s Telegram – February 2, 2012
Post-secondary education a privilege, not a right
By Paul Hussey
Us university lot are pampered pretty well here in Newfoundland and Labrador, if I do say so myself. Dirt-cheap tuition, a government that bends over backwards and falls to their knees at the students’ command, and Harvard-like admission averages of 65 per cent or better to get into Memorial University out of high school. (That last tidbit of information is sure to make all the Ferris Bueller-types at high schools from Bishops College to Burgeo Academy clean up their acts and hit the books extra hard to get their As in the final stretch, I’m sure.)
Now, we’re not lucky enough yet to receive free passes to the Spa at the Monastery just for showing up to classes each day – although, come to think of it, I’d love a MUN-sponsored massage right about now. But the way things are going, we may not have to wait until the next provincial election before all three parties start throwing around those types of promises.
In the meantime, yesterday marked the National Day of Action in this country, where student activists in this province rallied at Memorial University and other post-secondary institutions in protest of the federal government’s stance on post-secondary education. They want a collective vision for a well-funded post-secondary education system that builds a fair society, while combating corporate greed, and proclaiming that “education is a right.”
And it’s true – education is a right. It even says so in the United Nations’ Universal Declaration of Human Rights that “everyone has the right to education.” However, if you read a little further, it adds a little more detail on the subject: “Education shall be free, at least at the elementary and fundamental stages. … Technical and professional education shall be made generally available and higher education shall be equally accessible to all on basis of merit.” Key words: generally available.
While it’s admirable for activists from the student movement to proclaim that education is a right, post-secondary education isn’t a basic human right – it’s a privilege. And in Canada, any students that meet the standards of merit to gain entry into post-secondary institution – on the basis of scholastic achievement, or athletic abilities they can offer in the school’s environment – can do so while paying for it themselves, receiving student loans, non-repayable grant money and scholarships.
That’s the beautiful thing about Canada. Anybody can go to a post-secondary institution, no matter what socio-economic background they come from. But according to the Canadian Federation of Students (CFS) and the rest of the student activists across the country, this isn’t enough. In their minds, the value of post-secondary education should be held on the same level as other basic human rights, as something that no person should have to live without. And in all reality, they don’t. Any student in Canada that wishes to attend a post-secondary can do so, by paying – yes, young people have to pay for things, too – and not indebting the federal government on something that is worth its weight in gold. It might sound like a good idea at the time, but it’s more tax dollars that you and your grandchildren will be burdened with at another time.
If the CFS had its wits about it, it would spend less time arguing what is and isn’t a right, and spend more time communicating a stronger and more realistic message to Canadians on student issues. Either way, this province’s student activists have been holding our province’s governments at their mercy for quite some time now. If anyone’s going to convince the federal government that post-secondary education is a right, then it may as well be them. But with Harper still in power, there’s a better chance of hell freezing over.
Paul Hussey is an English and political science student at Memorial University, and news editor of The Muse.