Third day of hearings over for Christian Horizons – Waiting for a verdict…

Read the complete article here.

National Post – December 18, 2009
Human rights case: ‘I never felt like a hypocrite’
By Charles Lewis

TORONTO – A woman who was fired from a Christian charity organization for breaking the group’s code of conduct said yesterday she never believed that her sexual orientation made her less of a Christian or got in the way of her work.

For the past three days, Ontario Divisional Court has heard appeal arguments about a 2008 Ontario Human Rights Tribunal decision that said Christian Horizons, a charitable religious organization that tends to the severely disabled, had no right to dismiss Connie Heintz because she violated a morals code. The tribunal determined that Christian Horizons’ main purpose was serving the disabled, not teaching a creed, and therefore could not take advantage of an exclusion in the human rights code that allows religious groups to discriminate in hiring in certain cases. It fined Christian Horizons roughly $30,000 and ordered that the group develop an antidiscrimination code.

Christian Horizons, and several intervenors, said that the group’s ability to do its work depended on sharing common values as an evangelical Christian faith community, a part of which was a rejection of the sexual activity outside of traditional marriage.

Ms. Heintz, now 41, said yesterday in an interview she signed the code willingly when she joined Christian Horizons in 1995 as a group home worker. At the time she was wrestling with her sexuality, but had not yet come out, she said. “Speak to any person raised in a fundamentalist Christian background like I was – it is extremely difficult to come to terms with your sexual orientation,” she said after the hearing concluded yesterday. “You can’t flip the switch and decide.”

During the three-day hearing, lawyers for Christian Horizons noted that Ms. Heintz had also expressed doubts about her faith, another thing that alienated her from the group and their statement of faith. Ms. Heintz, who did not testify at the hearing, said she indeed had a “crisis of faith” as she was deciding to come out but still considered herself a deeply believing Christian. “You come out in phases by first coming out to yourself and then coming out to those closest to you. That process triggered a crisis of faith.”

In group homes for the disabled, workers tended to their clients by changing beds, serving meals and bringing them to medical appointments. The most specific religious duties were saying prayers and conducting Bible readings. Ms. Heintz said she felt she could do all those things despite being gay. “I never felt like a hypocrite,” she said.

Christian Horizons, the biggest provider of care for the disabled in the province, has 200 group homes, serves 1,400 patients and has a staff of 2,500. It has been in operation for 40 years.

During yesterday’s hearing, Cynthia Petersen, a lawyer for the gay rights group Egale Canada, said that Ms. Heintz also had a religious calling, which was thwarted when she was forced to go. “It was a restriction to her religious freedom. They don’t have the right to say she’s not an evangelical Christian.”

Read the complete article here.

Bookmark and Share

Comments are closed.


    $('#r-banner').cycle({
        fx:     'scrollDown', 
        easing: 'bounceout', 
        delay:  -4000 
    });