On the heels of New Democratic British Columbia MP Bill Siksay’s attempt in May to introduce a Private Member’s Bill (Bill C-390) allowing Canadians who object on conscientious or religious grounds to paying taxes for military purposes, the New Brunswick Court of Appeal has rejected a second appeal by Prince Edward Island pro-life activist David Little to object to paying taxes over abortion funding concerns. The appeal asked whether those who oppose abortion on grounds of ‘religion’ or as a matter of ‘conscience’ are relieved of the legal obligation to file annual tax returns and, by necessary implication, the obligation to pay taxes under Section 2 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Little was ordered by Revenue Canada to file missing tax returns in 2003, charged in 2005 and convicted by the New Brunswick Provincial Court in 2007. Little appealed the 2007 decision to the Court of Queen’s Bench and lost, filing a second appeal to the Court of Appeal in April. Little’s plight highlights a cruel double standard – while Siskay’s opposition to the war in Afghanistan is applauded by mainstream supporters, Little’s opposition to the war in the womb is all but ignored.



